Have you ever wondered what cleans baking sheets (cookie sheets) best? These are old, some are rusty, caked in buildup.

Use a Silicon Baking Mat to prevent messes (and save yourself a lot of work!)
➡ https://amzn.to/3rmeONB

I tried vinegar and baking soda, Easy Off oven cleaner, ketchup, Borax, Bar Keeper's Friend, hydrogen peroxide, Dawn Powerwash, Brillo Pads, Comet, Magic Eraser and even razor blades!!

Razor Blade
➡ https://amzn.to/3cZNnB9 (works on greasy oven glass too, just don't use dry, get it wet or use cleaner, test to be sure it doesn't scratch, surfaces are different)

Baking Sheet, we recommend a heavy aluminum one (nonstick are impossible to clean)
➡ https://amzn.to/31cWWdx

We may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

There are so many YouTube videos on how to clean baking sheets. But the best method depends on the kind of baking sheet you have. One method won't work on everything. Metals are all different. But I found a hack that worked best.

This was a marathon test!! I wanted to the cookie sheets sparkling like my successful (but difficult) baking sheet cleaning video.    • Clean Baking Sheets so they Look NEW ...  

What I learned is that EVERY BAKING SHEET IS DIFFERENT. Nonstick is different than regular baking sheets. And the higher quality baking sheets are better because they hold up longer and clean easier. So invest in QUALITY baking sheets and you'll use them for years to come!